5.3.6 Friendship and Equality
Saturday, 22. August 2009
“By means of the considerations that we have elaborated”, says Diderot in his article on Friendship, “we have thrown the light on a very important principle regarding friendship, to assume that friendship should find or establish equality between two people [in Latin: amicitia aut pares invenit, aut facit : friendship either finds or creates equals]. Therefore, is it possible for a Monarch to have friends? To have any, he must seek them among other Monarchs, or he must give to his un-king-like friends a character that is on an equal footing with sovereign power. This is the major significance of the principle.
In proportion to the issues that create friendship there must be between the two friends a freedom in feeling and language large enough to make sure that neither one is superior nor the other inferior. Equality must be found on both sides in the indulgence of the amicable contact. This indulgence consists in offering to each other their thoughts, preferences, doubts and difficulties, but always within the area of the character of friendship that has been brought into being.”
It is in this atmosphere that Diderot finishes his article, equality between friends is his cherished conviction. Now you might wonder if did Diderot had such friends himself?
He had indeed… as a matter of fact, he had some very good friends. And did he practise his beliefs on Friendship with them?
Let us deepen these questions as we continue…
AnnG Says:
Hmmm…. I think it is sometimes possible to have a friendship that is not so equal – for example, between a teacher and a pupil.
However, the nature of the relationship may change when the pupil perhaps gains in knowledge and experience, and the power dynamic is changed – especially if the pupil outperforms the teacher?
Cora Says:
No problems to be friends with my…yoga teacher nor with someone who runs a carpenter workshop. It gets a bit more tricky when I’m thinking of my GP…and my dentist…my friend the dentist, who knows all about my teeth and my thoughts… well, that should really not be a problem.
But… when one of my pupils should aim for a more amicable contact, I would be on my guard, always aware of the consequences of what I’m saying.
Therefore the friendship would not be between equals. Perhaps we need a new name for such contacts, not a friendship, but a ‘teacher/pupil’ something…